My #3 most hated theme here at Free Money Finance is the net worth formula from the Millionaire Next Door that determines whether or not your net worth is as high as it should be. Here are a few of the select comments about this lovely post:
I have read this book, I'm wondering if the formula must be adjusted, however for the earlier years in your life... For example, mid to early 20's. Most people in their twenties still have no positive net worth, when factoring in a car payment, student loans, and especially the newly found MORTGAGE on the house they buy. I, for example, have a negative net worth of around 180,000 - yet I am supposed to have a net worth positive of around 100,000. I don't think I've even made 100,000 total in my entire life yet!... There should be a way to adjust the formula for the younger years in life, when debt accumulation happens due to schooling and purchasing a home!
And as if that weren't enough:
I have to agree that this "rule of thumb" is more offbase than most "rules of thumb," especially for those towards the beginning or end of their careers...
And more:
I have to agree with the folks who question the validity of the rule of thumb for people early in their careers. It's especially problematic for young professionals. Take a young lawyer, for example. Three years out of law school, she might make $150K/year, at around age 30. Because she spent time in law school, she probably had no net worth built up when she started her job. But according to the rule of thumb, her net worth should be $450,000, or three times her current salary. That's just not realistic. The rule of thumb may only work once you've hit 35, or been working for some number of years (like 7-10).
And more:
The book formula is a poor rule--unless it was designed to use a biased rule to 'shock' people into saving.
Using misleading information to cause (scare) people into behavioral changes because one thinks s/he knows what is best for all people is risky as one solution does not fit everyone's unique circumstances. Even if that behavior is considered most reasonably to be a "good" one.
Makes me wonder what else from the book is misleading.
And on and on. Apparently, it's not a favorite of most people. ;-)
However, there is good news on the net worth calculation front. I've recently posted How to Compute Your Net Worth and Check Your Financial Progress and How to Compute Your Net Worth, How High Your Net Worth Should Be, and Be Sure to Do It Once A Year which have both received positive comments on the net worth formulas they include.
Recent Comments