The following is a guest post by Kent E. Irwin of eFinPLAN. Want to know which is better for you -- term or cash value life insurance? Read on.
Virtually all fee financial planners and writers today recommend that people should only buy term life insurance instead of one of the other types of life insurance that have cash value. The insurance industry of course strongly argues the merits of cash value insurance. Over the years I’ve witnessed many emotional discussions between the insurance industry, financial experts and the financial media about the type of insurance people should buy. I’ve been in both camps.
Prior to creating eFinPLAN financial planning software for consumers I was a fee only financial planner, holding the designation Chartered Financial Consultant or ChFC. During my 25 years experience in the financial services industry I have also sold life insurance, and worked in the home office of a life insurance company. In each of these roles I have tried to be an objective educator giving people good information so that they can make good decisions for themselves. The following discussion should provide some balance on the issue.
The conventional wisdom today regarding life insurance that only term insurance should be purchased may indeed be true for most people, however I think it is good to be informed about all the issues so that people can make well informed decisions.
Why do most experts recommend term insurance:
- Term costs less than other forms of life insurance both initially and over 10 to 30 years.
- Lower cost life insurance maximizes the amount of money someone can save and invest.
- Cash value insurance earns a low rate-of-return on the cash build up.
- Most people will not need life insurance when they are older if they have little debt and large investments.
Why life insurance agents recommend cash value insurance:
Cash Value insurance is also known as permanent because it lasts at least until age 100. Term insurance expires at the end of the term. Cash value insurance comes in many forms such as Whole, Universal and Variable life insurance. For a full grid comparing most insurance types, click here. The following are the major reasons insurance agents recommend cash value insurance.
- Cash value insurance costs less than term insurance, if you compare it over a long period of time.
- Cash value insurance forces people to save money, which is helpful to people who lack the discipline to save.
- Cash value insurance’s rate-of-return is comparable with the part of a client’s portfolio that might otherwise be invested in bonds or cash.
- Many people need life insurance in their older ages: Wealthy people for estate planning, middle income people who were unable to save enough to self-insure.
- Retirement income: Life insurance cash values grow tax-deferred and may be borrowed tax-free.
Costs & Need for Life Insurance Later in Life
Life Insurance provides protection. It is purchased to provide immediate cash so that loved ones are able to maintain a certain standard of living in case you die. Term life insurance is indeed the lowest cost life insurance initially and if you compare total out-of-pocket costs for premiums for the 20 or so years that most people need it most - when children are still at home and you have a mortgage.
However, there are situations in which people need insurance for longer periods of time. After divorce or death people start new families and have young children later in life. In addition to these “blended families” some don’t save enough and often carry too much debt. Therefore, if you compare term versus cash value insurance over very long time periods, cash value insurance may be lower.
Young people just starting out with new families, careers and mortgages are often at a point in time that their income is low, they have large needs and they can’t afford to compare long term costs. They need the lowest cost for their budget today, giving them maximum cash flow for savings and investing. Many people are underinsured for disability, if they have additional dollars, disability insurance should be a top priority.
Some agents suggest that if you have prosperous financial ventures, your net worth may some day be worth several million dollars. At that time you would need life insurance for estate planning. This may be true, however it is difficult to justify purchasing a lot of cash value life insurance when you are young on the chance of that future possibility. If you need it when you become wealthy, you will probably be able to afford it then.
Some may need life insurance in their older age to provide for their family. Bad decisions, setbacks, blended families and low savings may cause some in their 50’s to wish they had some life insurance other than term, because their term policy may soon expire or cost a lot to renew. They may also have health problems that may hinder their ability to obtain competitive life insurance.
Forced Savings, Rate of Return and Retirement Income
When I was a young insurance agent, one of the main motivations to encourage young people to buy cash value insurance was to force savings discipline. In actuality those that were undisciplined savers eventually let their policies lapse, and those that were disciplined sometimes cashed in their policies because they could see their other savings and investments growing faster. Instead of buying cash value life insurance to force savings they would probably be better off learning good budgeting habits and family financial management.
Is life insurance rate of return that bad when compared to other like investments?
Some argue: Since most people should have some of their investments in cash, money markets and bonds for safety, for reducing volatility and for emergencies – why not put some of that into cash value life insurance? Over the long term life insurance cash values from good policies and companies should perform in the middle single digits similar to a intermediate term bond. Some of the best policies may perform in the upper single digits – not bad for your “safe money.” However these cash value policies may take 5 to 15 years to break even, and much longer to earn these comparable rates of return. If you can afford to wait for these types of return, and are saving enough for emergencies and retirement, then you might want to consider cash value life insurance.
Life insurance is also sold to provide retirement income. Sometimes it is referred to as an IRA or 401(k) alternative, or under the LEAP system. Life insurance cash values grow tax deferred, and if properly arranged can be taken out in the form of loans without paying income tax. The computerized models of these programs can look competitive with other investments. Most advisors recommend that people take full advantage of the available retirement and IRA plans before ever considering such an approach. If you desire to investigate this, make sure that the agent provides computer illustrations that show results of lower rates of return and higher mortality and other expenses. Then perform internal rate-of-return calculations on these modest projections. If this still interests you, closely examine the insurance company and obtain quotes from other high quality insurance companies.
Conclusion
Term insurance is often the best decision for most consumers, especially for those with modest incomes and large needs. The first phase of financial planning, forming a secure foundation, usually begins with establishing an emergency fund, having adequate term life and disability insurance, and maximizing IRAs and employer sponsored retirement plans. Those with more mature financial plans may want to consider having a percentage of their life insurance to be the cash value type, depending upon their individual family circumstances, personal preferences, and overall financial circumstances and plan.