Free Ebook.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

« Net Worth Review: April 2007 (Woo Hoo!!!!!!!) | Main | We Need to Teach Our Kids the Basics of Personal Finance »

May 08, 2007


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

It's really hard to argue against buying an index fund.

Maybe with the exception of an even cheaper index fund ;)

Did anyone else read James Stewart's column in Smart Money that talks about "enhanced" index funds? I thought it made some interesting points about the psychology involved with settling for "just average" returns with index funds. And the idea that you can "enhance" an index fund and still use the term index fund!

Attempting to beat the index fund is usually a pretty dangerous game.

One exception maybe a tax advantage fund. It tries to mimics an index while trying to minimize your tax burden.

Sounds good in theory with what they do. I haven't spent enough time to know how, in the long run, they won't stray too far away from an index. It also hasn't been on the scene for long enough to show that it won't stray too far from the index.

I wouldn't really say it avoids style risk. That small value outperforms large growth over the long term is well known and an S&P index will overweight large growth and expensive stocks in general. That is the price of going with the flow. You will be buying tech stocks in 2000. It does form a solid base to start from though.

My husband and I are beginning start our 401k and his company offers 12-15 different fund options. There is only one index fund. We are thinking of putting 85% in the index and 10% in an international fund with 5% in a small & mid cap. But after reading some of your posts regarding index funds, should we do 100% allocation in the index fund?

There is something else crucial here, especially when it comes to your 401k.

The expense ratio (the fee that they charge you) pays a huge role in how much return you get. Your investment return is unpredictable, but your fees are pretty much set. So be really careful with how much you are paying!

Personally, my 401k offers one index fund and a bunch of other funds. Only the index fund offers a "reasonable" expense ratio. I put all my money into that one because they charge me an excessive amount for everything else.

That's just me though.

Lord --

You know you can get an index fund for almost any purpose, right? You can get a small cap index, for instance.

Amanda -- It depends on your goals, timeline, etc., but there's certainly nothing wrong with spreading around your money a bit. If you don't have small, mid, and international index funds, you'll have to go with what you can to get into those other areas of investment.

FYI -- I am NOT 100% in index funds myself. Not even close (though they make up a large part of my portfolio.)

The comments to this entry are closed.

Start a Blog


  • Any information shared on Free Money Finance does not constitute financial advice. The Website is intended to provide general information only and does not attempt to give you advice that relates to your specific circumstances. You are advised to discuss your specific requirements with an independent financial adviser. Per FTC guidelines, this website may be compensated by companies mentioned through advertising, affiliate programs or otherwise. All posts are © 2005-2012, Free Money Finance.