Here's a useful tip left as a comment on my post titled Idea for Saving: Put Your Change in "Savings" Every Night:
If you keep close tabs on your expenditures in a tool like Quicken, there is a way that you can simulate a loose-change piggybank. First, create a rolling transaction in your checking account dated a month in the future and with a category of "Loose change". Every time you enter a transaction, determine how much change would be required to take you to the next dollar. For example, if your grocery bill is $92.73, your "change" is $0.27. Add $0.27 to your rolling "Change" transaction to set it aside for investment and make sure it won't be spent. Then, once a month, take all the money you've set aside as "Change" and move it to your savings account or some other investment vehicle. I haven't tried this yet but it's pretty tempting and I might do it at some point.
I'm not big on "tricks" like this to make me save (I don't have any trouble saving on my own), but I do understand that many people need/could use something like this to help them accumulate a good amount of money during the course of a year.
Interesting savings trick!
Posted by: Money Blue Book | January 17, 2008 at 02:42 PM
Isn't this essentially what the Bank of America account they were promoting heavily earlier this year does? For every transaction you round up to the nearest dollar and the change gets deposited in savings.
Posted by: Dan | January 17, 2008 at 03:54 PM
In days of yore, when people had to learn how to add & subtract and balance their checking accounts by hand, it was easy to make believe that your account was short. Each month, you would subtract some amount from your current balance, physically leaving it in the account, and making believe it didn't exist. Of course, when you got your monthly statement, you would simply subtract that amount from the actual balance. At some point, you would write a check to your savings account or spend that money.
You can simulate that in Quicken or Money by creating a fake savings account and setting up a recurring transfer into the account.
Of course, the surest way to save would be to set up a real automatic draft to an Internet bank.
Posted by: JimmyDaGeek | January 17, 2008 at 04:09 PM
Bank of America does this with their Keep The Change program. In addition to rounding up to the next dollar and transfering it into your savings, they also match 5% of you total Keep The Chang transfers (once a year).
I've participated in the program since it was started and have seen little to no savings from it (~$15 net in savings a year), then again my BoA accounts are my budgeted to the last penny accounts so they tend to maintain the minimum balance and then only what I plan on spending on fixed bills anyways.
Posted by: Adam | January 17, 2008 at 04:56 PM
Bank of America still does this but they match 100 percent for the first three months. Sweeeeet.
Posted by: Ron@TheWisdomJournal | January 17, 2008 at 05:19 PM
Keep in mind that Bank of America savings accounts offer next to nothing in interest -- I think 0.5%. I would suggest getting that 5% match and RAPIDLY moving your money to a higher yielding account -- prehaps ING, HSBC Direct, or Emigrant.
Posted by: Jake | January 17, 2008 at 05:59 PM
I consider $5.00 bills as my atomic spending unit. That is, if I need to purchase it something I pull out a $5.00, a $10.00, a $20 bills etc. I leave the singles & coins be.
I get home all go into a coffee can and I do not take them to the bank until they fill up. I have small coffee cans for pennies and nickels and put dimes and quarters into a big can. Dollars also go into a big can.
Last time I cashed in, my big can was dimes, nickels, and quarters and had something like $400.00 in it. Came in handy for that trip we took to the Philippines.
I have been doing the dollar bill thing for about one month now and have about $100 set aside. I am thinking of turning them into $20 bills and put them in our fireproof safe. Nice little emergency cash fund, comes in handy (got a tow once and the tow truck operator would only take cash payment no credit cards no checks we had it).
Posted by: Mark Framness | January 17, 2008 at 10:22 PM
Etrade bank also has pretty good rates - I think I'm around 5%.
Posted by: Kevin | January 18, 2008 at 01:12 PM
There are a couple other ways to do this in Quicken.
One is to set up an account, round up the transaction and do a split. I've been thinking of starting my own "Keep the Change" type program, but I download my transactions into Quicken and this might cause issues.
Another is to use the Savings Goals feature and make contributions to the goal. When you reach the goal and are ready to use the money, just delete the goal and all the change is "back." This is probably the method I will use.
Posted by: Nathan | January 20, 2008 at 09:50 PM