Free Ebook.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

« Why the Roth Conversation Is A Bad Deal For You | Main | The Story of Joseph »

March 28, 2009


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

How would that even work at Target? Whom do you ask? The cashier, so far as I know, isn't empowered to make any decisions.

Hmmm, I love saving money but man am I a wimpy bargainer!! I'll go out on a limb and try it but I'm not sure where.

Along with Matt H - I would like to understand how this would work @ Target. Or IKEA. Or any large chain where it seems like the prices are very standard, and where there isn't exactly a pile of inventory sitting around.

Please elaborate in another post. :)

Like some of the other people who commented, I'm not sure how this phrase will work at Wal Mart but I really like this phrase and see how powerful and useful it can be.

I think another good use for this phrase would be for one to ask themselves that in every situation. It would certainly be a good self-improvement technique!

Man, that has been my favorite phrase for at least a year now. Word for word it is amazing to use. I've cut phone bills, cable bills, buying used appliance within the last couple months with it.

Great job!

I tried it yesterday when we needed a stove from an appliance store, but the salesman said he couldn't do anything. Not even include a $20 hose that we needed for free. The stove was already discounted but it would have been nice to feel like I was in control.

From a retailer's perspective, if after I have spent 15 minutes or more helping an indecisive customer finally make a choice and he then comes out with a phrase like that, well, God bless him, I might ask him to leave! I'm sure it's worth a try anyway though.

As a member of the corporate retail world, I don't think this phrase would fly in any stores where prices are mandated by a group of VP's who are operating off of a corporate business plan. To walk into a multi-billion dollar store (ie: wal-mart) and try to haggle down the price of a TV would seem a waste of time considering it is a corporate price strategy that has a specific life-span tied to the retail price. This phrase seems best suited for an environment where competition determines the price structure. It works in an environment where the gatekeeper is given freedom to work with a range of prices (ie: mattress suppliers, cell phones, cable companies, auto dealerships, and hotels). The strategic goal of "is that the best you can do?" is to put the other party on notice that you are willing to walk away if they can't lower the price. This type of interaction makes no difference to the salesperson at Best Buy or Wal-Mart...but makes a lot of difference to hotels and auto dealerships who are fighting for market share and customer satisfaction.

I had this work at a large national retailer once. They had put a large number of down comforters on clearance and I asked if they'd do anything for me if I bought all of them. The manager did mark them down 15% more and I sold them all on eBay for a decent profit. I guess the moral of the story is you never know. I was going to buy them anyway, and asking saved me close to $600.

Everything is negotiable. Don't let anyone kid you it is not. In retail you have close outs or over stocks. They want to get rid of them so why not ask. The days of asking for a better price are here.

To everyone saying it won't work at Ikea, Target, Walmart, etc. please just let me say I've done it.

Ikea has an open item section for things that have been returned and old floor models. I've gotten them to knock down the price on these and give discounts when buying multiple items.

Target has clearance items and will frequently sell the last display unit when things go on clearance.

Walmart has been known to have damaged merchandise from time to time and is usually flexible when merchandise is near to expiring.

Places like Best Buy will discount a TV if you buy a service plan, online retailers will give discounts and toss in free shipping if you're buying the last item in stock and it they discover it's been damaged, and lots of times big ticket items can be heavily negotiated when you're making a cash offer.

I have had these stores knock down prices to 30% off what they were asking for a clearance item which was already 75% off the original sales price, and I've gotten surprising discounts at every single store I've mentioned. Sometimes the offers they make are simply staggering, and some huge chains care less about getting full price and more about just moving the inventory to clean out space for newer items with a higher margin. If the choice is to right off a non-moving item and junk it or at least make some money off it, sometimes they'd rather make whatever they can and move on to the next money maker.

A polite smile, kind words, and a simple request will get you very far. Just keep trying, and you might be surprised.

As a store manager for a small independent business I want to add that it is important to ask nicely. If someone just comes in and says "Is that the best you can do?" in a rude and imperious manner, well, then that will be probably be the best I can do. I like to sell things, sure, but I also like to be treated like a human being, and I like my staff to be treated like human beings. So go ahead and ask, but ask nicely and understand that even then there may not be any latitude even from an independent retailer for a discount. We know that we cannot match the prices of large chain retailers let alone online retailers. We hope that people value the service and convenience we offer and that their "bottom line" considerations also include what kind of community they value. Is the cheapest price the only consideration? If so perhaps we should just outsource our entire economy to China, unless of course when we ask if that's the best they can do and we get a better answer from Bangladesh!

When I tell my friends about the discounts I get they always ask me how I get a discount and I always tell them by asking.

I went into a large home improvement store and bought a patio set for less than 50% off just by asking and they still had 3 sets left. It works very well when you buy multiples of something. I bought 3 shower heads and asked if I could get a discount, sales person on the floor said yes and got 10% off on top of the 20% it was already marked down. Just by asking!

I've got mixed feelings about this. Even in a big box store, there's a certain margin assigned for profit. When that goes down, prices don't get dropped -- payroll gets cut. So the customer gets a discount (when one wasn't planned for) but it comes at the expense of the daily sales total. And then the hours get cut for the employee. I realize people want to have a bargain, but those dollars get have to come from somewhere, and they don't come out of the fatcat's pockets.

It's one thing if, across the board, people are only willing to pay X for an item, not X+Y. But random discounts don't track to the individual item: the option for "customer haggling" isn't traceable as a discount (there are types of discounts and those are recorded.)

When the store I was at cut payroll, they started with cutting the 40hr week people down to just under 40 (so they don't have to pay benefits.) Then they cut hours across the board, so there are fewer employees doing the work of their missing counterparts. So those people who really needed that low-pay job aren't getting their hours.

If the store is genuinely losing money because it's not able to sell enough product then that's one thing. But artificially driving down revenue through haggling is something different. Yes, people should be wise about their money. But they should also be mindful about how their choices impact on those around them.

The store owners would rather have the sale than not. But they're not going to lose their jobs when the store performs poorly: it'll be that worker who really needed that job that gets the pinch.

I think those words are quite useful in attempting to get some better discounts. I especially use it when I've had to negotiate some outlier utility bills and with my cell phone plans to get some amazing perks.

Me: "I've been on hold for X minutes now, can I get a courtesy credit" etc.
Them: "How does $ sound?"
Me: "I appreciate that, but is that the best you can do?"
Them: "Let me check. Okay - how about $ + $"

And I do endorse the book as well. It's an easy read and while most of the material is obvious, it's presented in a refreshing manner.

The only problem is if everyone starts to ask for this it will no longer be effective. You need to figure out how to change your game up when negotiating.

For example the underlying principle in negotiation is that everyone is fair and reasonable- so is there a specific reason why they should do the best for you? If not, shouldn't you be in the same boat as every other consumer, which by the way is the underlying assumption behind fixed pricing... everyone pays the same price because all customers are equal. Stores also use differential pricing to try and get people who would pay more, do pay more. Often by nicer packaging or small product features that aren't worth the value.

Other negotiation techniques are changing the quantity and see the effect on price as well as changing the time shape of money (pay now or pay over installments), discount for cash, discount for last years model, discount for a floor model, discount for an unpopular color. Or you can always ask if there any upcoming promotions or sales. Generally the more research you do the better off you are but eventually you hit the laws of diminishing returns. Even if you are not working, your time does have some value.


I'm lousy at bargaining so that phrase will come in handy!

Nice article! I think this 'seven' magic words could make any company to offer 'better' products to the consumers!

I'll try it. LOL

It works in hotels sometimes and def. with customer service online or on the telephone.

Will link to this in my blog!

I always love reading about negotiating tactics. I'm not sure how well this would work at a Target but will remember the next time I call T-Mobile.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Start a Blog


  • Any information shared on Free Money Finance does not constitute financial advice. The Website is intended to provide general information only and does not attempt to give you advice that relates to your specific circumstances. You are advised to discuss your specific requirements with an independent financial adviser. Per FTC guidelines, this website may be compensated by companies mentioned through advertising, affiliate programs or otherwise. All posts are © 2005-2012, Free Money Finance.